Schedule/Submission review/Wiki Culture and the Community

Wiki Culture and the Community

Group 1

No.	Title	Presenter (first author)	Vote1 (Harel)	Vote2 (Ijon)	Vote3 (Deror avi)	Vote4 (OrsolyaVirág)	Vote5 (aude)	Vote6 (TXiKi)	Vote7 (Beria)	Vote8 (Sasha)	Final Score	comments	Submitter attending?
5	"Get Jimmy off my screen!" - the donations model for the 2010-2011 fundraiser	Philippe Beaudette and Megan Hernandez	A		SA	SA	SA	SA	SA		SA 6.8	Panel
6	Accessibility and Wikipedia	User:AniVar and User:Santhosh.thottingal	SA	SA	SA	SA	SA	SA	SA			Did they get a scholarship?	Not sure. Did not get scholarship.
7	Account Creation Improvement Project	Lennart Guldbrandsson	SA	SA	SA	SA	SA	SA	SA		SA 7		Yes
8	Best practices in mentoring programs	Tim Moritz	A	A	SA	A	SA	SA	SA		SA 6.8	I suggest to simplify the structure of this session - not sure we need three separate working groups or that we'll have time for that. Keep it more streamlined.	No, Ireas and Nemo bis will undertake the session.
9	Biography of living people : "Sorry I'm not dead"	Thierry Coudray	A	A	SA	A	A	A	SA
10	Categorization system strengths and pitfalls	SpeedyGonsales	A	WA	SA	A	A	SA	WA		A 6.25		Yes
11	Challenges encountered when working on Wikimedia projects for endangered languages	Carlos Manuel Colina	SA	A	SA	A	SA	SA			SA 7	Suggest cooperation with submission 107.	Yes
12	Changing the world, one law at a time (Lobbying for Wikimedians)	Mathias Schindler	SA	SA	SA	SA	SA	SA			SA 7	I would put on emphasis on making this talk accessible for an audience without much legal knowledge or understanding of the nuances of copyright.
13	Chiara Ohoven and the strange tale of German Leistungsethik	Dirk Franke	A	WA	A	WA	A	WA			A 5.66		Yes
14	Collaborative Diplomacy	Tiffany Smith	A	SA	SA	SA	SA	WA				Panel (?). Might have special appeal for the local Israeli audience. O.:This sounds great but I can't vision it as a panel.
15	Cooperation across different Wikipedia languages - the death anomalies case study	WereSpielChequers	A	SA	SA	WA	SA	SA			SA 6.75	Need to better explain what the project is about inside the abstract (not behind the link). O.:I couldn't realize what the project is about.	Yes
16	Cultural Configuration: Autoreferentiality in Wikipedia	Marc Miquel		WR	SA	WA	A	SA				Asaf: concept clear; point/goal of talk unclear. O.: I agree.	Yes
17	Editor Satisfaction Survey	Manuel Merz		WA	N	WA	WA	N				Someone wrote: If the survey is being conducted in June, will results be ready? Asaf adds: this looks like something that should be shared digitally and discussed over a longer time. Manuel: Yes, preliminary results will be ready as a basis for discussion. Final results will be released digitally under a free license.	Yes
18	Editor Survey	Barry Newstead			SA		SA	SA				Asaf: merged into #20	Yes
19	Editor trends - Wikipedia PT	Jonas Augusto Xavier		R	N	N	N	WR				Asaf: too narrow for Wikimania	Yes
20	Editor Trends Study and Other WMF Research	Howie Fung, Steven Walling, Diederik Van Liere			SA	SA	SA	SA		A		Asaf: I work for the WMF, so I abstain	Yes
21	Encouraging Participation in Wikimedia Projects	Brandon Harris, Howie Fung, Steven Walling			SA	WA	SA	WA				Asaf: I work for the WMF, so I abstain	Yes
22	Everything You Know About Wikipedia Is Wrong	Kat Walsh, Fluffernutter, Ironholds, Kim Bruning, and James F		SA	SA	SA	SA	SA				A full panel - 1.5 hours	Ironholds - maybe, dependant entirely on the presentations Fluffernutter - not registered yet, but yes Kat: yes James F.: Yes. Kim : definitely if talk = true;
23	Flagged Revisions - a step forward never taken?	Victoria Doronina			SA	A	A	A					Yes
24	From a group of volunteers to a professional team	Beatriz Busaniche			SA	SA	SA	SA
25	From on-wiki conflicts to real-life collaboration	Milos Rancic			A	WA	WA	A				O.:Milos, your presentation is not really well described. Could you pls add more info?	Yes
26	GLAM partnerships in the real life	Adrienne Alix			A	A	A	WA					Yes
27	Global distribution of our community and readers	Erik Zachte			SA	A	A	N					Yes
28	GlobalMelt	Michelle Thorne			A	A	A	WA				workshop	Yes
29	Grey Revolution: Motivating Older Persons to Participate in Wikipedia	Karen Torben-Nielsen, Jonathan Bennett, Stijn Bannier, Rüdiger Glott & Beat Estermann			SA	SA	SA	A				Workshop	Karen Torben-Nielsen: Yes. Stijn Bannier: Yes.
30	Growth and development of Wikimedia Deutschland	Sebastian Moleski			SA	SA	SA	SA				Requesting 45 min; A: Perhaps put in session w/ 24? O.:Good idea!	Yes

Group 2

No.	Title	Presenter (first author)	Vote1 (Harel)	Vote2 (Ijon)	Vote3 (Deror avi)	Vote4 (OrsolyaVirág)	Vote5 (aude)	Vote6 (TXiKi)	Vote7 (Beria)	Vote8 (Sasha )	Final Score	comments	Submitter attending?
31	Hippies with guns: how ideological conflict shapes Wikipedia and what we can learn from it	Oliver Keyes/Ironholds	A		N		WA	SA	N		WA 5.25		Maybe, dependant entirely on the presentations.
32	How Rules and Resources Constrain Social Memory on Wikipedia: the case of 2011 Japan earthquake	Emmanuel Wathelet and François Lambotte	WA		SA	A	WA	A	SA		A 6.2		Yes
33	How scary is Wikipedia for non-machos?	Karen Torben-Nielsen & Jonathan Bennett	SA		SA		A	SA	A		SA 6.75	A: Do we accept both this and #29 (workshop)? Can they be combined?	Yes
34	How to spam wikipedia and get away with it	Decora	WA		WA		WR	WR	R			B: I love the name, maybe we should do another presentation with this name.
35	How to Start a Party on Six Continents	Jay Walsh, Steven Walling, Moka Pantages	A		SA		SA	SA	SA		SA 6.75		Yes
36	How Wikipedia spreads to other media	MADe	A		A		SA	SA	WA		A 6	Based on presentation made in Gdansk B: Did he get a scholarship?	Yes
37	Iberocoop: Regional cooperation in action	Galileo Vidoni, Ivana Lysholm & Osmar Valdebenito	A		A		SA	A	- -		A 6	B: I'm involved in, so i will not vote.	Yes
38	Inclusionism, deletionism, bot created articles and notability exceptions correlated with user satisfaction	SpeedyGonsales	A		WA		N	N	SR		N 4	B: As a debate on-wiki might work, but as a presentation is too biased to be accepted.	Yes
39	Intercultural Issues Across Wikimedia Projects	Delphine Ménard	A		SA		SA	A	SA		SA 6.5
40	Intopedia - Ask not what Wikipedia can do for you - ask what you can do for Wikipedia!	Hans-Jörg Happel, Ben Romberg	SA		WR		N	WA	N				Hans-Jörg: yes if approved; Ben: no
41	Language policies on the Tagalog Wikipedia	Josh Lim, Joseph Ballesteros, Eugene Villar and Frederick Calica	A		A		A	WA	WA		A 5.5		Lim: yes Ballesteros: yes Villar: yes Calica: will ask
42	Let's get local!	Sylvain Boissel	SA		A		A	A	WA		A 6	Requesting 30 min	Yes
43	May it please the court	Kat Walsh	SA		SA		SA	SA	SA		SA 7		Yes
44	Missing Wikipedias	Milos Rancic, Jon Harald Søby	A		SA		SA	SA	A		SA 6.5		Yes
45	National-Scale Wiki for Rights and Benefits	Amity Korn	N		N		WR	WR	WR	N	N 3.5	Could this become a Wikimedia sponsored project? If not, is Wikimania the appropriate venue?	Yes
46	Our educational wikis - pros and cons of Wikipedia	Paul Bacsich	N		WA			N	WR
47	Participating in research projects	Mathias Schindler, Angelika Adam, Denny Vrandecic, Dario Taraborelli	A		SA			N	A		A 5.75	Panel - (perhaps for chapters conference?) B: Together with 52	Yes
48	People are Knowledge	Aprabhala, Mohau, Shijualex, Mayur	SA		SA			SA	A		SA 6.75	Film + presentaion + discussion = 1.5 hours. Might be too long in this format.	Yes (three of the presenters will be)
49	Philippines in a Colonial, Commercialized, and Fascist Education	Michael Angelo Rivera	N		WR			SR	R
50	Project Internet in Sweden	Johan Jönsson and Jan Ainali	WA		SA			A	A		A 6		Yes.
51	Readership Survey	Barry Newstead	A		SA			A	A		A 6.25	Possible overlaps with numbers 18, 20, 100 to be clarified and settled.	Yes.
52	Reflecting knowledge diversity	Mathias Schindler, Angelika Adam, Denny Vrandecic	A		SA			SA	A		SA 6.5	Panel. Possible overlap with 47 - needs to be resolved or clarified. B: Together with 47	Yes
53	Revival of Sanskrit language	Vibhijain	A		N			A	WR			B: Not sure if that is a appeal or a submission	No, But I will like to submit my presentation.
54	Revival of the Hindustani Language and the Role of Wikipedia	Hindustani Language	SA		A			A	R		WA 5.25	B: As a panel or a discussion, yes. As a presentation i don't imagine would work.	No
55	School-sized-Wiki	Luiz Paulo O. Pereira da Silveira	A		WA			SA	N			Did he get a scholarship?
56	Simulacrums of Wikipedia in Polish press - Comparative and Historic perspective	Bartosz Kosinski	WA		A			A	N
57	Small Wikipedias, Great Expectations: Following the campaign for the development of the Greek-language Wikipedia.	Ilektra Pavlaki	SA		SA			A	WA		A 6.25		Dependent upon submission approval.
58	Sport Wiki Academy	Laura Hale	WA		WA			WR	WR
59	Stand Up, Speak Words, Spread WikiPassion	Florence Devouard	SA		SA			WA	SA		SA 6.5		Anthere: yes of course !
60	State of the GLAM: DC	User:Aude	A		SA		- -	A	WA		A 6		Yes

Group 3

No.	Title	Presenter (first author)	Vote1 (Harel)	Vote2 (Ijon)	Vote3 (Deror avi)	Vote4 (OrsolyaVirág)	Vote5 (aude)	Vote6 (TXiKi)	Vote7 (Beria)	Vote8 (Sasha)	Final Score	comments	Submitter attending?
61	Strategies for Wikinews	Milos Rancic	A		SA	A	A	A	A		A 5.8	B: With 94	Yes
62	Support the miners - improving quality by boosting editors work	Denis Barthel	SA		SA	SA	SA	SA	SA		SA 7		yes
63	Taking Wikipedia in Higher Education to the next level	Frank Schulenburg	SA		SA	SA	SA	SA	SA		SA 7	B: Togheter with 92 and 96.	Yes
64	Taxonomy of Indian (Bharatiya) Religious Literature since Vedic times	B S N Prasad	WR		R	R	SR	SR	SR		R
65	The line of sufficiency	Kiril Simeonovski	A		WA	WA		WA	WA		WA 5.25	workshop	Yes
66	The Volunteer Response Team: Willing hands working unseen	Alice Wiegand	A		SA	A		A	SA		A 6.25		yes
67	The Wiki-Indian	Swaroop G Rao	A		SA	SA		A	A			B: If he is not going to Wikimania, who will present that if approved?	No
68	The Wikiclinic Project	Claudia Ivette Herman and Vladimir Herman.	A		A	A		A
69	The Wikipedian Condition	Josh Lim	A		WA	WA		A				Did he get a scholarship?	Yes, and I got a scholarship. :)
70	Volunteer Response Team Workshop	Alice Wiegand	A		SA	A		WA			A 6	Workshop (see also 66 above). Maybe just have one of them because of overlap.	yes
71	War and Peace: Writing Wikipedia Social Histories	Maryana Pinchuk and Victoria Doronina	A		A	A		SA			A 6.25		Maryana: can't make it, unfortunately!
72	Webfonts	Santhosh.thottingal	SA		N	N		WA				Tutorial. Very important to smaller languages. (Did he get scholarship?)	Not sure. Did not get scholarship.
73	What next in GLAM?	Liam Wyatt	SA		SA	SA	SA	SA			SA 7		Yes
74	What place for companies on Wikipedia ?	Christophe Henner	A		SA	A		WA
75	What Readers Want	Christine Moellenberndt	WA		SA	WA		SA					Unfortunately unable to attend.
76	Where Wikipedia has gone wrong, what we can do to bring it back on track	Dror Kamir	A		SA	A		SA			SA 6.5	symposium	yes
77	Wiki Loves Monuments	Multichill & Lodewijk Gelauff	SA		SA	SA	SA	SA	--		SA 7	B: I'm organizing it in Portugal, so i will not vote.	Yes, Yes
78	Wiki Migration	Dr. Vadim Zaytsev	WA		WA	WA		A	N		WA 5.25		Yes.
79	Wiki to LaTeX	Dirk Hünniger	SA		A	A		N	N				No
80	Wiki-based National Content Development	Susanna Mkrtchyan	A		A	WA		WA			A 5.5		Yes.
81	WikiAfrica: Call for last mile operators	Isla Haddow, Iolanda Pensa	A		SA	A		SA	SA		SA 6.5		Yes.
82	WikiGuides and new users	James Alexander	SA		SA	SA		WA	A		SA 6.5	Discussion+workshop.	Yes
83	Wikimedia and the Public Domain	Ryan Kaldari	WA		SA	A		A	SA		A 6	Panel - maybe put in legal track. O.: I agree.	Yes
84	Wikimedia Chapters	Lodewijk Gelauff	SA		SA	SA	SA	SA	SA		SA 7	Perhaps should be made into some kind of mini plenary because of overarching importance. B: I agree. Maybe a 1 hour plenary.	Yes
85	Wikimedia events	Phoebe Ayers & friends	A		SA	A		SA	SA		SA 6.5	Workshop. So many different kinds of events - maybe we need better focus? O.: I think this would be great with #35. I left a note to Phoebe. B: I agree with OrsolyaVirág, and loved the "& friends" ;)
86	Wikimedia in Turkey	Tahsin OZUN	WA		A	WR		SR	R	WR	WR 3.4	Submitter should provide more details in abstract. (Less than 50 so far.)	Yes, also added information.
87	Wikimedia Mobile Panel	Tomasz Finc, Mani Pande, Patrick Reilly, Parul Vora, Kul Wadhwa	SA		SA	SA		A	A		SA 6.75	Panel - duplicates with other submissions by Finc. (O.:Maybe it would fit better in the tech. group.) B: togheter with 106.	Parul Vora - Yes; Kul - Yes; Patrick Reilly - Yes; Mani Pande -No; Tomasz Finc - No
88	Wikimedia outreach efforts in India	Tinucherian , ShijuAlex	SA		SA	SA		SA	A			Did not get a scholarship - so not arriving B: Togheter with 67.	Yes both Tinu & Shiju is now attending
89	Wikimedia projects in Classical languages - An overview of Challenges and Growth prospects	Surya Prakash	A		WA	A		A	A			Has a scholarship? No. B: Since he is not comming, who will present that?
90	Wikimedia technical staff vs. the World	Guillaume Paumier	A		SA	A		A	SA		A 6.25		Yes

Group 4

No.	Title	Presenter (first author)	Vote1 (Harel)	Vote2 (Ijon)	Vote3 (Deror avi)	Vote4 (OrsolyaVirág)	Vote5 (aude)	Vote6 (TXiKi)	Vote7 (Beria)	Vote8 (Sasha)	Final Score	comments	Submitter attending?
91	Wikimoney	S.M. Belmonte	SR		R	R	SR	SR	SR		R	O.: It will be released as a book, anyway.
92	Wikipedia and Academia: Experiences from the Campus Ambassadors Program in the US and UK	Sadads	SA		SA	SA	SA	SA	A		SA 7	O.:Could be in the same panel w/ 63. did he get a scholarship?	Yes I am coming, got a scholarship.
93	Wikipedia and beyond: Incentivizing the engagement for freely licensed material and projects	Nicole Ebber	SA		SA	SA		SA	A		SA 7		Yes.
94	Wikipedia and Wikinews: differences between news articles and encyclopedic news	Iván Martínez and Dennis Tobar	SA		A	A		A	SA		A 6.25	O.:Could be incorporated with 61.	DT: Yes IM: Yes
95	Wikipedia as UNESCO World Heritage - a status report	Catrin Schoneville	A		SA	SA		A	SA		SA 6.5		Yes
96	Wikipedia Chapters in Institutions of Higher Learning	Kosgei K. Isaac	A		SA	A		A	WA
97	Wikipedia Illustrated	Galia Offri & Mushon Zer-Aviv	SA		A	A		A	A		A 6.25	workshop + talk	Yes
98	Wikipedia is afraid of governments	Deryck Chan	WA		SA	A		A	A		A 6		Yes
99	Wikipedia Neutrality Disputes Correlate with Political Instability	Robert B. Russell	WA		A	A		WA	N
100	Wikipedia Survey: The final results	Stijn Bannier, Ruediger Glott	SA		SA	SA		SA	SR		A 5.8	Possible overlaps with number 18, 20, 51 to be clarified and settled. B: this survey is 4 years old and the results was given in Wikimania 2008. Not a good idea have a presentation with a outdated survey.	Stijn Bannier: Yes. Ruediger Glott: Undecided.
101	Wikipedia Takes Your City	Ryan Kaldari	A		SA	SA		A	A		SA 6.5	tutorial	Yes
102	Wikipedia used to be cool	Christophe Henner	SA		SA	A		A	SA			O.:Could be together with 100. H: I find it super important.
103	WikiProject: Public Art	Sarah Stierch	A		SA	A	SA	A	A		A 6.4	O.:Did she get a scholarship? Yes.	Yes
104	Wikis considered as least energy systems: Cultural and community implications for accuracy	Richard Farmbrough	A		A	WA		WA	N		A 5.5		Yes
105	Wikis Love Leaders!	Michal Buczynski	SA		WA	A		N	N			A 5.5	Yes
106	WMF Mobile Research	Parul Vora, Mani Pande and Kul Wadhwa	A		SA	SA	SA	SA	SA		SA 6.8	See also 87 above (perhaps only one of the two) - unite the two! Did they get scholarships? (they are WMF staff! - no scholarships) A: Put 3 mobile submissions together into one session? B: Is the best option, Aude	Parul Vora - Yes; Kul - Yes
107	Workshop. Projects in languages with singular status	Joan Ramon Gomà i Ayats	A		WA	WA		SA	N		A 5.75	Need to be better define and explain "singular status".	Yes